Methodology
Kestrel methodology: where every number comes from
Collectors trust TCGplayer and eBay sold comps — not mysterious app prices. This page says exactly where Kestrel’s numbers come from, how often they refresh, and what a clear buy/pass lean means before you act.
Market price
Market price is the Near Mint quote we attach to a catalog card — primarily TCGplayer-linked US board quotes. When a live pull is unavailable, we fall back to the last saved board quote rather than inventing a number.
US and EU views stay labeled. We do not blend Cardmarket EUR into a fake USD “average.” If sources disagree beyond FX noise, treat that as a warning — not a single blended truth.
AI fair value + fair range
A nightly training run fits a price model on history and writes an AI fair estimate plus a fair range — the band where the model is allowed to speak.
A clear call means confidence gates are green. Then Radar can say cheaper than fair (buy lean) or richer than fair (pass lean). When gates fail, Kestrel stays quiet instead of forcing a tip.
Radar, Deal of the Day, and Trade
Deal of the Day and the public Radar preview show capped underpriced picks. Full Radar adds filters and the full cheaper / richer desk.
Trade Analyzer scores both sides on market and fair so you see fair / you-ahead / them-ahead — the same vocabulary as the buy/pass desk, not a sticker-sum alone.
Comps, grading, and sealed
Card detail can surface eBay sold comps next to the board. Sold clusters are the industry check against ask-price noise — use them before you trust a thin print.
Grading EV frames fees and slab paths; it never guarantees a PSA 10. Sealed quotes use verified product ids — showcase art must match the named product.
Refresh cadence and human checks
Catalog updates, history, model retrain, and quote saves run on a nightly schedule. Live detail pulls may refresh prices within API quota limits.
We also sample clear Radar calls by hand against TCGplayer and eBay sold. A hard fail blocks paid marketing — price trust is the product.
FAQ
- Is Kestrel a replacement for TCGplayer?
- No. TCGplayer remains the market standard for asks. Kestrel answers whether that market price looks cheap or rich versus AI fair value — then deep-links you back to marketplaces.
- Why do some cards have no Radar call?
- Weak history, weak confidence, or quarantined prices. Silence is intentional — better than a loud wrong tip.
- Do you blend US and EU prices?
- No. Sources stay labeled. EUR views use FX conversion for display where configured; they are not averaged into a secret “true” price.
More guides: all guides · fair value · grading · trade fairness